Investigation of resonant phenomena in a locomotive wheelset on the basis of calculation of natural frequencies and modes of their oscillations on finite element models

From the practice of engineering design it is known that in the development of mechanical systems, the operation of which is certainly not based on the phenomena of resonance, self-synchronization, etc., one should be wary of the proximity of the frequencies of free oscillations in such mechanical systems in different forms. Transient processes are dangerous due to the excitation of significant quantities of mechanical stresses and their damage to structures before destruction. This effect can also be appeared in wheel pairs (WS) of locomotives during operation. On the finite element model (FE) of the electric locomotive wheelset, calculations of natural frequencies and vibration modes are performed, the case of torsional oscillation frequencies with the participation of the electric drive gear and bending (saddle-shaped) oscillations of the running wheels is demonstrated, which can accelerate the processes of origin and development in its fatigue cracks. Paper discusses methodical issues of performing such calculations, problems of assessing the degree of danger of proximity of vibration frequencies of structural elements. The prototype of the finite-element model considered in the article was the WS of a locomotive with an asynchronous transmission, a one-way reducer and a composite retaining wheel. Methodical issues of performing such calculations, problems of assessing the degree of danger of proximity of vibration frequencies of structural elements are discussed. The results of calculations in combination with their visualization give a fairly complete idea of the behavior of the wheelset in the traction drive, while allowing studying the stress-strain state of its parts, and also providing an opportunity to identify the damaged elements and zones. It is highly advisable to carry out similar studies on virtual models when analyzing the operation of locomotive structures and assemblies under extreme operating conditions (for example, in case of boxing), which is not practicable or dangerous by experimental methods. It is possible, as shown, and it is necessary at the design stage of the WS to conduct its frequency analysis in the manner described in the article and, based on its results, perform a resonant detuning in a constructive or software way in the frequency range of the modulation of the operation of an asynchronous drive. To this end, by analogy with the AAR S-669 standard (USA), it is necessary to develop a domestic regulatory document for the projected locomotives with an asynchronous drive.

wheelset, frequency and form of free oscillations, saddle shape of running wheel oscillations, origin and development of fatigue cracks

1. Grek V. I., Mikhaylov G. I., Volokhov G. M., Oguenko V. V. Opyt sozdaniya i ispytaniy kolesnykh par i ikh elementov dlya innovatsionnogo podvizhnogo sostava [Experience in the creation and testing of wheelsets and their elements for innovative rolling stock]. Vestnik VelNII [Bulletin of the JSC All-Russian Scientific Research and Design Institute of Electric Locomotive Industry], 2016, no. 1, pp. 38 – 51.

2. Makhutov N. A., Gapanovich V. A., Kossov V. S., Ogan'yan E. S., Krasyukov N. F., Volokhov G. M. Metody opredeleniya resursa i tsiklicheskoy prochnosti konstruktsiy ekipazhnoy chasti lokomotivov [Methods for determining resource and cyclic strength of the carriage- part of locomotives]. Transport: nauka, tekhnika, upravlenie, 2016, no. 10, pp. 3 – 12.

3. Makhutov N. A., Kossov V. S., Ogan'yan E. S., Volokhov G. M., Gasyuk A. S., Krasyukov N. F., Protopopov A. L. Metody opredeleniya resursa konstruktsiy lokomotivov [Methods for determining the resource of locomotive designs]. Zhivuchest' i konstruktsionnoe materialovedenie (ZhivKoM-2016) [Viability and structural materials science (ZhivKom-2016)]. Moscow, IMASH RAN Publ., 2016, pp. 76 – 81.

4. Standard S-660. Wheel designs, locomotive and freight car — analytic evaluation. Adopted: 1981; Last Revised: 2009. AAR Manual of Standards and Recommended Practices Wheels and Axles. USA, 1981, 8 p.

5. Gordon J., Perlman A. Estimation of residual stresses in railroad commuter car wheels following manufacture. Proc. of the IME Congress in Anaheim, CA, November, 1998, no. 15. ASME RTD, USA, 1998.

6. Gordon J., Perlman A. Estimation of residual stresses in railroad commuter car wheels following manufacture. Final Report, MA 02142-1093, June 2003. U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Railroad Administration, Research and special programs administration John A. Volpe, National Transportation systems Center. Cambridge, 2003, pp. 13 – 19.

7. Standard S-669. Analytic Evaluation of Locomotive Wheel Designs. Adopted: 2011. AAR Manual of Standards and Recommended Practices Wheels and Axles. USA, 2011, 18 p.

8. Oganyan E. S., Ovechnikov M. N., Volokhov G. M., Krasyukov N. F., Protopopov A. L., Mishin A. A., Zakablukova N. K. Approbation of US AAR-660 and AAR-669 standards` criteria for rolling stock wheel durability research. Proc. of 17th International Wheelset Congress, September 22 – 27, 2013, Kiev, Ukraine, part 2. Kiev, 2013, pp. 161 – 172.