Long-term optimization of operating costs: an analysis of the US railways tests
https://doi.org/10.21780/2223-9731-2017-76-2-74-84
Abstract
Reformation of railway transport, one of the goals of which is to optimize transportation costs, should be based not only on improving the management system, but also on the combination of technical, technological and marketing innovations. Russian railways will benefit from the experience of reforming US Class I railroads - the largest railway system in the world, as a result of which specific operating costs were reduced by more than 3.5 times with a quantitative and qualitative growth in the transportation offers.The prerequisites for reforming the railway industry in the United States were deterioration of railways condition, decrease in the quality of service, a deficit in the car fleet and, as a result, a significant decrease in the share of rail transport in the freight turnover of the whole transport system.In a competitive market, the deregulation of the railway system has made it possible to reduce both the transportation tariffs and the costs of railway companies that are able to respond quickly to consumer preferences.Optimization of operating costs for vertically integrated railways in the United States was achieved through systemic growth in productivity of all types of resources: infrastructure, labor, rolling stock and fuel. Due to this it is provided a long-term cost optimization, rather than a tem-porary decline, followed by a compensatory growth.The main driver of efficiency growth was the introduction of technical/technological and organizational/managerial innovations, which resulted in the replacement of more available jobs with fewer high-tech jobs, which allowed to increase labor productivity by almost 5 times.At the same time, in the period from 2005 to 2015 there was a slowdown in the growth of quality indicators and even some of their decline, which was caused by the approach to the maximum in terms of technical and technological capabilities levels of intensity of resource use and, accordingly, depletion of reserves. Removing constraints on the growth of efficiency requires the activation of innovation activity with additional motivation for this based on market factors.The experience of the US railways requires careful consideration when solving the problems of increasing the efficiency of Russian railways, naturally, taking into account their inherent economic and technical-technological characteristics.
About the Authors
D. A. Macheret
Joint Stock Company “Railway Research Institute” (JSC ”VNIIZhT”); Moscow State University of Railway Engineering of Emperor Nicholay II (MIIT)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
N. A. Valeev
Joint Stock Company “Railway Research Institute” (JSC ”VNIIZhT”)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. Misharin A. S., Sharonov A. V., Lapidus B. M., Chichagov P. K., Burnosov N. M., Macheret D. A. Programma strukturnoy reformy na zheleznodorozhnom transporte s kommentariyami [Program for structural reform in rail transport with comments]. Moscow, MTs‑ FER Publ., 2001, 240 p.
2. Izmaykova A. V. Klassifikatsiya innovatsiy na zheleznodorozhnom transporte i investitsionnyy faktor ikh realizatsii [Classification of innovations in railway transport and the investment factor for its implementation]. Vestnik VNIIZhT [Vestnik of the Railway Research Institute], 2015, no. 3, pp. 35 – 41.
3. Macheret D. A. O chem svidetel'stvuet stoletnyaya dinamika pokazateley krupneyshikh zheleznodorozhnykh system [As evidenced 100-year dynamics of indicators of the largest railway systems]. Ekonomicheskaya politika [Economics policy], 2016, Vol. 11, no. 6, pp. 138 – 169.
4. AAR. Railroad Facts. Washington, DC, Police and Economics Department Association of American Railroads, 2016, 86 p.
5. Rotbard M. K. K novoy svobode. Libertarianskiy manifest: per. s angl. [To the new freedom. The libertarian manifesto: transl. from engl.]. Moscow, Novoe izdatel’stvo [New Publishing] Publ., 2009, 398 p.
6. AAR. Railroad Facts. Washington, DC, Police and Economics Department Association of American Railroads, 2002, 72 p.
7. Khusainov F. I. Zheleznye dorogi i rynok. Sb. statey [Railways and the market. Coll. of articles]. Moscow, Izdatel’skiy dom “Nauka” [Publishing House “Science”], 2015, 582 p.
8. Saakyan Yu. Z., Trudov O. G., Savchuk V. B., Alekseev E. A., Kurotchenko I. V. Mirovoy opyt reformirovaniya zheleznykh dorog [World experience in reforming railways]. Moscow, IPEM Publ., 2008, 276 p.
9. Valeev N. A. Kriterii optimizatsii zatrat lokomotivnogo kompleksa [Criteria for optimizing the costs of the locomotive complex]. Vestnik VNIIZhT [Vestnik of the Railway Research Institute], 2014, no. 6, pp. 59 – 62.
10. Khusainov F. I. Ekonomicheskie reformy na zheleznodorozhnom transporte [Economic reforms in railway transport]. Moscow, Novoe izdatel’stvo [New Publishing] Publ., 2012, 192 p.
11. Mizes L. Byurokratiya. Zaplanirovannyy khaos. Antikapitalisticheskaya mental'nost': per. s angl. [Bureaucracy. Planned chaos. Anticapitalistic mentality: transl. from engl.]. Moscow, Delo Publ., 1993, 240 p.
12. Bubnova G. V. Mezologistika kak instrument formirovaniya mezhdunarodnykh proizvodstvennykh sistem [Mesologistics as a tool for the formation of international production systems]. Ekonomika zheleznykh dorog [Railways economics], 2015, no. 4, pp. 13 – 20.
13. AAR. Railroad Facts. Washington, DC, Police and Economics Department Association of American Railroads, 2008, 90 p.
14. Lapidus B. M., Macheret D. A., Ryshkov A. V. Metodicheskoe obespechenie rynochnykh mekhanizmov ekonomicheskogo upravleniya na zheleznodorozhnom transporte [Methodical support of market mechanisms of economic management in railway transport]. Moscow, MTsFER, 2007, 160 p.
15. Smekhova N.G., Kozhevnikov Yu. N., Macheret D. A., Elizar'ev Yu. V., Potapovich N. A., Shobanov A. V., Inozemtseva S. M. Izderzhki i sebestoimost' zheleznodorozhnykh perevozok [Ecpenses and prime costs of railway transportations]. Moscow, FGBOU “Uchebno-metodicheskiy tsentr po obrazovaniyu na zheleznodorozhnom transporte“ [FGBOU “Educational and Methodo-logical Center for Education in Railway Transport“] Publ., 2015, 472 p.
16. Macheret D. A. Proizvoditel'nost' – fundamental'naya osnova ekonomicheskoy effektivnosti [Productivity is the fundamental basis of economic efficiency]. Ekonomika zheleznykh dorog [Railways economics], 2010, no. 7, pp. 19 – 34.
17. Macheret A. A. Ekonomicheskaya otsenka povysheniya proizvoditel'nosti ispol'zovaniya resursov zheleznodorozhnogo transporta [Economic evaluation of productivity of rail transport resources]. Ekonomika zheleznykh dorog [Railways economics], 2015, no. 10, pp. 35 – 40.
18. Lapidus B. M. Problemy i zadachi povysheniya proizvoditel'nosti truda v OAO “RZhD“ [Problems and tasks of increasing labor productivity in JSC “Russian Railways“]. Byulleten' Ob"edinennogo uchenogo soveta OAO “RZhD“ [Bulletin of the Joint Scientific Council of JSC “Russian Railways“], 2016, no. 3, pp. 1 – 16.
19. Kapelyushnikov R. I. Ekonomicheskie ocherki: Metodologiya, instituty, chelovecheskiy capital [Economic Essays: Methodology, Institutions, Human Capital]. Moscow, Izdatel'skiy dom Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki [Publishing house of the Higher School of Economics], 2016, 574 p.
20. Feylo M. B. Kriterii i urovni investitsionnykh proektov [Criteria and levels of investment projects]. Mir transporta [World of transport], 2012, no. 6(44), pp. 82 – 85.
21. Bastia F. Ekonomicheskie garmonii. Izbrannoe: per. s frants. [Economic harmony. Favorites: transl. from french]. Moscow, Eksmo Publ., 2007, 1200 p.
22. Izmaykova A. V. Ekonomicheskaya otsenka innovatsionno-orientirovannogo razvitiya zheleznodorozhnogo transporta. Kand. ekon. nauk diss. [Economic evaluation of innovation-oriented development of rail transport. Cand. econ. sci. diss.]. Moscow, 2016, 182 p.
23. Acemoglu D., Robinson J. A. Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperty and Poverty. N.Y., Crown Publ., 2012, 546 p.
24. Shumpeter Y. A. Teoriya ekonomicheskogo razvitiya. Kapitalizm, sotsializm i demokratiya: per. s angl. [The theory of economic development. Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy: transl. from engl.]. Moscow, Eksmo Publ., 2008, 864 p.
25. Macheret D. A., Izmaykova A. V. Novye pokazateli dlya otsenki kachestva i effektivnosti raboty zheleznodorozhnogo transporta [New indicators for assessing the quality and efficiency of rail transport]. Ekonomika zheleznykh dorog [Railways economics], 2015, no. 6, 30 – 35 pp.
26. Macheret D. A., Izmaykova A. V. Innovatsionnye podkhody k izmereniyu i povysheniyu kachestva raboty zheleznodorozhnogo transporta [Innovative approaches to measuring and improving the quality of rail transport]. Ekonomika zheleznykh dorog [Railways economics], 2015, no. 10, pp. 74 – 77.
27. Macheret D. A. O razrabotke sistemy kompleksnoy otsenki i povysheniya proizvoditel'nosti ispol'zovaniya proizvodstvennykh resursov po napravleniyam (trudovye resursy, infrastruktura, podvizhnoy sostav, energoeffektivnost') [On the development of a system of integrated assessment and increased productivity of the use of productive resources in the areas (labor, infrastructure, rolling stock, energy efficiency)]. Byulleten' Ob"edinennogo uchenogo soveta OAO “RZhD” [Bulletin of the Joint Scientific Council of JSC “Russian Railways”], 2010, no. 2, pp. 3 – 23.
28. Lapidus B. M., Macheret D. A., Miroshnichenko O. F. Povyshenie proizvoditel'nosti ispol'zovaniya resursov i effektivnosti deyatel'nosti zheleznykh dorog [Increase productivity in the use of resources and the efficiency of railways]. Ekonomika zheleznykh dorog [Railways economics], 2011, no. 6, pp. 12 – 22.
29. Lapidus B. M. Nauchnoe obespechenie innovatsionnogo razvitiya i povysheniya effektivnosti deyatel'nosti zheleznodorozhnogo transporta: kollektivnaya monografiya chlenov i nauchnykh partnerov Ob"edinennogo uchenogo soveta OAO “RZhD” [Scientific support of innovative development and increase of efficiency of railway transport activity: collective monograph of members and scientific partners of the Joint Scientific Council of JSC “Russian Railways”]. Moscow, Mittel- Press Publ., 2014, 288 p.
30. Valeev N. A. Upravlenie zatratami v lokomotivnom komplekse zheleznodorozhnoy kompanii. Kand. ekon. nauk diss. [ Management of costs in the locomotive complex of the railway company. Cand. econ. sci. diss.]. Moscow, 2016, 132 p.
31. AAR. Railroad Facts. Washington, DC, Police and Economics Department Association of American Railroads, 2015, 86 p.
32. Muginstein L. A., Shenfeld K. P. Razvitie tyazhelovesnogo dvizheniya gruzovykh poezdov [Development of heavy haul transport of freight trains]. Moscow, Intext Publ., 2011, 76 p.
33. Mokir G. Rychag bogatstva. Tekhnologicheskaya kreativnost' i ekonomicheskiy progress: per. s angl. [Wealth lever. technological creativity and economic progress: transl. from engl.]. Moscow, Izdatel'stvo Instituta Gaydara [Gaidar Institute Publishing], 2014, 504 p.
34. Pittman R. Ya veryu v konkurentsiyu [I believe in competition]. Vektor transporta [Transport vector], 2014. no. 1, pp. 14 – 17.
35. McCloskey D.N. Measured, Unmeasured, Mismeasured and Unjustified Pessimism: A Review. Essay of Thomas Piketty’s Capitalism in the Twentieth Century. Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics, Vol. 7. No. 2, Autumn 2014, pp. 73 – 115.
Review
For citations:
Macheret D.A., Valeev N.A. Long-term optimization of operating costs: an analysis of the US railways tests. RUSSIAN RAILWAY SCIENCE JOURNAL. 2017;76(2):74-84. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.21780/2223-9731-2017-76-2-74-84
Views:
839
.jpg)
Email this article 